Title: Approaching the Possible – The World of Stargate SG-1
Author: Jo Storm
Publisher: ECW Press
Oversized paperback, 523 pages
List price $19.95, but available from Amazon.com for $12.97
My overall impression of this book is that it is well researched, informative, and entertaining. The first one hundred or so pages of the book exam the origins and history of Stargate SG-1. Next up is a comprehensive episode guide through the end of Season eight (I really like the layout of the episode guide). Lastly, there are 10 pages of resources and bibliography. At this point I have read the first section in its entirety and flipped through the episode guide and resources. I’ve enjoyed the book enough that I plan to purchase a copy for myself. Right now I’m reading Sue’s book sent by way of aizjanika.
From what I have seen so far, the author is fairly even-handed and unbiased in her discussion of the various characters. Mind you, that doesn’t mean that I agree wholeheartedly with everything she says. I think any book that discusses a TV show (or a movie or a play or anything similar) is going to be subjective to some degree since every person who watches that show will have their own unique view of it.
However, Ms. Storm isn’t afraid to say negative things about the show when warranted. She is just as likely to point out episodes that missed the mark as she is episodes that went beautifully – what worked, what didn’t quite work, and what failed abysmally. This is a look at the show as it really is. I think many of the folks reading this review are most concerned with how Ms. Storm handled the characters of Daniel and Sam - afraid there will be Belittling for Daniel and Exultation for Shippy Sam. Truly, I didn’t see that. I thought that Ms. Storm had good things to say about Daniel and wasn’t afraid to say negative things about Carter. Ms. Storm discussed the plusses and minuses about each character, each episode, and each season. Here I’ll just concentrate on the good things about Daniel and the bad things about Carter for the benefit of those worried that the opposite would happen.
Ms. Storm comments throughout the book on how very popular the character of Daniel Jackson is, as well as how talented the actor is. She seems respectful of Shanks’ talent and abilities as an actor and the fan reactions that Daniel and Michael engender. Storm doesn’t go into such detail on those subjects for either Richard Dean Anderson or Christopher Judge. For example, in the bio section on Michael Shanks she gives much information regarding his various theater roles and how that experience helped him “to hone his acting talent and develop a working method, as well as an ability to analyze and work with narrative structure and character motivations.” (pg. 31) On the next page she notes that Shanks’ portrayal of Daniel “quickly shot him to fan fame” and “endeared him to a large contingent of fans, who from the start, were extremely vocal about their love of the character, and of the actor himself.” She begins a discussion of Shanks’ acting awards with “It is not only the fans who have recognized Michael’s talent: critics and award organizers have been consistently supportive of his performances. Since the year 2000, Michael has proven to be one of the most popular stars on television.” (pg. 35)
When it comes to discussing Shanks leaving the show at the end of season five, the author quotes Michael Shanks himself, using his own words to explain his reasons for leaving. She doesn’t try to gloss over the uproar it caused, either. His leaving is discussed in detail both in his bio section and the section “Through The Stargate Season by Season”. In the latter, she notes the fan reaction and campaigns to save the character as well as how Daniel’s absence affected the next season.
As for the character of Samantha Carter, Ms. Storm quotes Amanda Tapping on page 45 of her bio section: “I hated [Carter] in the beginning…she was very linear, one-dimensional, standing on her feminist soapbox, with this raging diatribe about equality…”. In the Season by Season section, Ms Storm notes “Other characters had a tougher time getting off the ground, especially Samantha Carter and Teal’c…Carter was written as both a scientist and a soldier, but neither aspect was well-developed enough for viewers to be able to grasp the character’s personality or potential.” (pg. 52) The author spends half a page here discussing the flaws in the Carter character as initially written. The flaws in the character of Teal’c needed only a few sentences.
Later in that same section, Ms. Storm tackles the Jack/Sam Ship head on and makes it very clear that this is a sore subject with fans. “…the controversial episode ‘Divide and Conquer’ aired (and was there ever an episode more aptly named, given its divisive effects on the fans?)…..Season four is still referred to by some as the ‘shipper’ (relationship) season….It’s also one of the most controversial seasons, because many of those not interested in a potential relationship between Sam and Jack were annoyed by the constant return to the question.”
Hopefully, the examples above will give you a feel for how the author handles Daniel and Sam. I found the book very interesting.
The front sections are:
The World of Stargate SG-1 (a brief history of speculative fiction, specifically in regards to science fiction and fantasy)
Making Myth: The Story of Stargate SG-1 (the history of the movie and the very beginning of the television show)
The Cast of Stargate SG-1 (cast bios in alphabetical order)
Behind Stargate SG-1 (brief overview of the main themes, narrative and dynamics of the show)
Through the Stargate, Season by Season (a look at the overall story arcs and direction of the show for each season as a whole)
Everybody CanCon: Stargate SG-1 In the Great White North (explaining some reasons for filming in Canada)
Coding the Wormhole: An Interview with GateWorld’s Darren Sumner Out of the Blue: The Franchise of SG-1 (a look at what ‘official’ merchandise is, or isn’t, available)
No Red Shirts: The “Fanchise” of SG-1 (a look at the highly active and involved on-line fan community)
Stargate SG-1 Episode Guide - The episode guide fills 400 pages, covers eight whole seasons, and is a lot of fun to flip through. Each episode is laid out in the same format beginning with the episode
number and
title,
original air date,
writer,
director, and a one-line synopsis of the plot followed by a discussion of the episode in terms of theme, character development, symbolism and such. This isn’t just a restatement of what happened scene by scene in the story. This looks at what the author calls “deep story structure”. What are the issues in this episode? How are the characters affected? What worked well in this episode? What didn’t? Next we have
Gods & Scientists which gives details on either a bit of science or a myth seen in the episode,
Interesting Fact which gives a tidbit of info about making the episode,
Why We’re Space Monkeys which highlights the things in the episode that set Stargate apart from other science fiction shows, and
Parlez-Vous Gate? which has fun snippets of dialogue from the episode.
Resources (non-fiction books on Stargate, online magazines, and websites devoted to the show or its stars)
Bibliography (Seven pages of sources used in the book)
There are two things that would improve this book for me: an index, and a listing of the guest stars in each episode. Other than that, I quite like it and am looking forward to getting my own copy.